Primary Colors: Why One Set Wouldn't Suffice

Colors are a ubiquitous fact of human life. Imagine a world without colors; all of the great masterpieces would be painted in gray scale, that potato could be purple or brown and there would be no more blue skies. Experientially, we are highly familiar with the concept of colors, but I would say it isn’t common to understand the more technical side of the world of colors. Let’s explore this more analytical side and it’s applications as we try to answer a question most of us have probably had: why are there multiple sets of primary colors?

At the most basic, colors are categories of light within the visible spectrum that can be described as having either different wavelengths or frequencies since the two variables are directly correlated by the equation

                     1. c=λv (c is the speed of light, λ is wavelength and v is frequency)

The visible spectrum is comprised of the rainbow colors describe by the acronym ROYGBIV (red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo and violet). 

Fig. 1: Visible spectrum for humans (Arstechnica)

White is the presence of all wavelengths while black is the absence of light. Technically, there is no physical meaning associated with colors since the color spectrum is defined based on human capacity to perceive and differentiate different colors. That is to say, the visible spectrum and colors would be defined very differently had we been insects able to see UV light [1]. So keep in mind that all of this talk of analyzing colors is human-specific and don’t go off trying to explain it to your dog.

The human eye consists of rods, which perceive low intensity light, and cones, which perceive colors and high intensity light [2]. There are three types of cones, dubbed L, M and S, that respond to different wavelengths of light. The peak sensitivities for these three cone types are 580nm (red), 540nm (green) and 440nm (blue) respectively, adding to a maximum sensitivity at 560nm (in the yellow-green region of the spectrum) [3].

Fig. 1: L, M and S cone response curves and response sum (Cyberphysics)

This should start to sound familiar for those of you who are familiar with the concept of primary light colors or who have ever squinted really hard at a television screen. Aside from these three colors, other colors are perceived by simultaneous stimulation of multiple cone types. The color mixing ratios of red, blue and green light to perceive every color was actually indexed in 1931, creating the RGB CIE 1931 system [4]. The impact of breaking each color into three values of red, blue and green, called the RGB tristimulus values, is that each color can now be defined in three-dimensional space as a combination of three basis vectors representing red, blue and green relative intensity values. The mathematical derivation can be found in reference 4, but the result is the chromaticity diagram familiar to aficionados of tech wanting to know what range of human-perceivable colors their devices are capable of displaying. Look along the edge of the chromaticity diagram and you should find a color wheel for light.

So far we have one set of primary colors consisting of red, blue and green that has widespread applications in electronic devices since many of these generate colors for humans to perceive when watching movies or reading billboards and such. But this set of primaries and its corresponding wheel only apply to the production of light by adding ranges of wavelengths together. This is called additive color. When light is absorbed by colored materials via quantum effects, as has been described in Thoughts in Black Ink, the color perceived is the light range that has not been absorbed. To describe the phenomenon of light absorption to generate a reflected color, the painter’s wheel was invented by Isaac Newton in 1666 [5] with the familiar primaries of red, blue and yellow. What this wheel describes is how subtracting light with certain ranges of wavelengths stacks to reflect light of a certain color when starting with ambient pan-frequency white light. However, this is not strictly subtractive color because the painter’s wheel adds to brown, not black as anyone who has tried to make black paint from the primaries in art class knows. The subtractive color wheel is defined with yellow, magenta and cyan as primaries and should be familiar as the different ink cartridges you probably put in your printer so that your computer can print black in theory (but black ink is cheaper).

Fig. 2: Additive and subtractive color (Mac Developer Library)

Why these three colors? It turns out that if you take the three primary colors of light, red, blue and green, and combine them two at a time, you get cyan, magenta and yellow [6]. And since the color of a surface is what the surface doesn’t absorb, each subtractive primary color cancels out one of the additive primary colors until no light is left. And there you have it, the three most common primary color sets.

This post was made in response to a comment by my friend Lilia back on the article How Soap Helps Us Clean. I haven’t address the comment until now because I knew there would be a biological component to this explanation and cellular biology is not my strong suit, hence the brevity with which I describe the rods and cones of the eye. But if you guys have anything you would like to hear about, feel free to leave suggestions in the comments below and I will do my best to write a post for you. Thanks!

Party Science, Part 2: The Lights

If you haven't already, please read Party Science, Part 1: the Beats.

So, now that we’ve got the beats, what’s next? How about we get some lights to set the mood. Today’s installment: the lights.

Again we’ll start with a simple question: what is light? Simple question, not so simple answer. To skip a lot of gritty stuff, let’s just start with the premise that light is a form of electromagnetic radiation consisting of orthogonal electric and magnetic field components and behaving as a transverse wave while also as a particle… yeah. Anyways, there are many types of light bulbs that we can use for different effects. For typical houselights, incandescent bulbs with tungsten filaments that utilize blackbody radiation were used until recent years. Currently, compact fluorescent light bulbs (CFLs) are popular for efficiency reasons with LEDs on the rise. CFLs work by ionizing argon gas and mercury vapor with tungsten filaments by thermal electron emission to produce UV radiation. The UV radiation is then converted to visible white light by phosphors either on the bulbs or on their housing [1]. LEDs utilize the junction between semiconductor material doped with electron rich or electron poor elements relative to the semiconductor valence number (p-n junction) to produce light as the electrons from the negatively-doped material fall into lower-energy electron "holes" in the positively-doped material. With these typical lights we have some basic lighting. Now what are we going to do about colorful lights for that true party feel? The college DIY option would be to put colored plastic or something over house lights to get the same effect as a colored bulb at a fraction of the cost!

Fig. 1: Procedure for colored lamp perfection (Dornob)

But how does doing this produce colored light? The first thing to notice is that the colored filter is, in fact, colored (huh, imagine that). What this indicates to us is that whatever the material is made of or coated with, it is only transmitting light that comprises the observed color. In other words, the material is absorbing a portion of the visible spectrum of light and we see a net color as a result of this absence. This could be due to a number of factors, for example the presence of transition metal compounds or conjugated organics, but the general property that allows a material to absorb light is a possible electron energy state transition corresponding to a frequency in the visible spectrum. When applied, the colored filter acts on the white light emitted from the light source, filtering out the characteristic absent spectrum and producing a net color. And with our bargain colored lights in place, how about we go for a special effect to top it all off. Let's use some blacklights. Blacklights are fluorescent lamps tubed in black-coated glass to absorb most visible light and coated in phosphors that permit only UVA light (not UVB, which causes sunburn, or UVC, which is filtered out by our atmosphere naturally and would give you super sunburn, a.k.a. cancer) to exit. The UVA radiation produced interacts with phosphors in white clothing from laundry detergents, with natural phosphors in teeth and nails and with fluorescent clothing to produce the psychedelic colors that are associated with blacklights [2]. With beats and lights, our party is going strong.

Below I’ve posted a video of Russian hip hop artist Kristina Si that depicts multiple types of lights employed at a party. Take notes people.